What CPG's leaders said on November 17

Sources and links

On Tuesday afternoon we logged on to “A Conversation with CPG Leadership” with our question already sent and no idea whether it would be read. About thirty-five minutes in, Frank Armstrong, the Church Pension Group’s chief operating officer, said this:

“We’re exploring, seeing if there’s additional transition support we can make without putting undue financial risk on the plan and on the employer.” (34:50; CPG’s recording, about 34:13)

In August the answer was “no grandfathering.” (Webinar recording, about 50:30) So something has moved. We’re grateful to Mr. Armstrong for saying it in public, about a decision he told the audience he is “personally still agonizing over.” (30:45)

Ten minutes later the moderator, the Rev. Canon Arlette Benoit Joseph, came back to it. She said she was condensing the questions about GLP-1 coverage, asked about “the transition period”, and added, “we’ve seen the petition and we’re listening.” (44:34; CPG’s recording, about 44:11) That was our convener’s question in short form. The petition is the letter that 733 of you have signed.

What “transition support” means so far

Not much yet, and Mr. Armstrong was honest about that. “I don’t have an answer yet for that,” he said. (45:11) What he described was “some financial support”, arranged through Digbi Health, the program the Medical Trust offers from January 1, “in that sort of first quarter time.” He didn’t say how much, who would qualify, or whether a member would have to join Digbi’s program to get it.

So CPG is willing to help, and the help it described looks like three months of money toward buying the medicine yourself.

Why three months is not a transition

We want to say this before a plan is announced, while it can still change. Help that ends in March moves the day people stop from January 1 to April 1. A transition should carry people to 2028, when a new plan design can take effect, so that no one stops in the spring only to start again in January.

  1. Stopping and restarting wastes what everyone has put in. Any new option for 2028 starts on January 1, 2028. Someone whose help ends in March goes nine months without, then starts over. The Wegovy label says a person who misses two or more doses in a row goes back to a lower dose and climbs again. By the labels that climb takes about four months for Wegovy and about five to reach Zepbound’s highest dose, with a prescriber’s visits along the way. (Help if you’re losing coverage)
  2. The health the plan has already paid for is lost in the gap. After stopping semaglutide, people regained about two-thirds of the weight within a year, and blood pressure, blood sugar and cholesterol followed. (The evidence)
  3. Others who ended this coverage gave people longer. Colorado’s state plan kept members already in treatment covered at a higher copay. Ohio let existing approvals run until they expired. Connecticut’s Medicaid program ended up giving people already in treatment about seven and a half months after it stopped new prescriptions.
  4. By CPG’s own numbers, a year of direct purchase costs less than half of coverage. Mr. Armstrong said health plans pay “more than twice” what a person pays buying directly. So paying the full direct price for everyone now in treatment, for all of 2027, would cost less than half of the “over $10 million” CPG forecasts for covering them.

Our letter asks for six to twelve months. Twelve is what gets people to 2028 without stopping.

CPG’s reasons, in its own words

We said in the letter that we know the pressure CPG faces, and Tuesday gave us more of the picture.

  • “This decision was not based on ideological thought or any sort of value judgment. It really came down to economics and affordability.” (30:45)
  • The forecast has gone up. Covering these medicines in 2027 would now mean “over $10 million of additional costs that we would have to absorb by raising premiums at least 4% higher”, after use rose again in September and October. In August the figure was $8.9 million. (The facts on one page)
  • Manufacturers charge health plans “more than twice the amount on average” that a person pays buying directly, so CPG would rather “support access of these GLP-1s through direct consumer purchasing channels.” (31:40, 32:36)
  • Mr. Armstrong named what that does to members: “it’s sort of a shifting, somewhat, of financial burdens. We recognize that.” (33:27) He also said that “some people were first finding out about this when they were making annual enrollment decisions.” (34:50)

If buying directly costs less, the fourth request in our letter already asks for it: a plan contribution toward what members pay.

What we didn’t hear

  • Anything about members prescribed these medicines for heart disease, sleep apnea or liver disease. Mr. Armstrong described the change as ending coverage “for the primary diagnosis of weight loss” (30:06), and CPG’s enrollment guide says the exclusion applies “with or without comorbidities.” (The facts on one page)
  • Anything about 2028.
  • How many members are in treatment.

Two other things worth knowing

Quantum Health. Mr. Armstrong said Quantum “is not yet at the consistent delivery” CPG expects on prior authorizations and claims. (39:29) He and Mary Kate Wold, CPG’s president, meet Quantum’s chief executive in early December, and CPG is “looking at the marketplace for other evolving solutions.” (40:25) If Quantum can’t solve your problem, he said, call CPG’s client services team. (48:07) More on Quantum Health.

General Convention. Canon Benoit Joseph invited anyone considering a resolution about CPG’s work to talk with CPG “early in the process.” (42:27) We will take her up on that. Twelve seats on the Church Pension Fund’s board are up for election in Phoenix in 2027. (43:31) More on how trustees are elected.

This week

We deliver the letter on Tuesday, November 24, and the trustees meet December 9 to 11. (CPG, A Message from the Chair, Fall 2026) If you haven’t signed, sign the letter. If you have, send this page to one colleague who was not on the call.

The quotations here come from our own recording of the public webinar, and each time links to that moment in the transcript. CPG posted its own recording on November 18. We checked every quotation against its captions, and they match. CPG’s video starts about a minute after ours, so take a minute off our times to find the same moment there. If we have misheard anyone, please tell us and we will correct it publicly.

If one member suffers, all suffer together with it.