Transcript: A Conversation with CPG Leadership, November 17, 2026
This is our own transcript of “A Conversation with CPG Leadership,” which the Church Pension Group (CPG) held on Zoom on Tuesday, November 17, 2026. Our summary is in What CPG’s leaders said on November 17.
- We made it from a recording of the public webinar. Software transcribed it and the text was checked against the audio.
- CPG posted its own recording on November 18. We compared this text with its captions. The differences were filler words and spelling, and nothing that changes what was said.
- Times count from the start of our recording. CPG’s video leaves out the host’s opening reminders and starts about 54 seconds later, so take about a minute off our times to find the same moment there.
- “[?]” follows a word we could not make out for certain. “[sic]” marks a slip kept as it was spoken.
- The moderator read participants’ questions aloud. No participant is named.
The speakers were Mary Kate Wold, CPG’s chief executive officer and president; Frank Armstrong, chief operating officer; Michael Hood, chief investment officer; the Rev. Canon Arlette Benoit Joseph, chief church relations officer, who moderated; and Jermaine Hadaway, the host.
The parts about GLP-1 coverage start at 25:20 and 44:34.
If we have misheard anyone, please tell us and we will correct it publicly.
Welcome and opening prayer
0:12 Jermaine Hadaway: Good afternoon, and thank you all for joining. I’m your host, Jermaine Hadaway, and this is a Conversation with CPG Leadership webinar. I have a few important reminders to go over with you before we actually begin. Just letting you know that this is Zoom webinar, so you will automatically be muted as you enter[?]. Please do not try to unmute, as we do not need any noise or interruptions disturbing the presenters while they are presenting. If you have a question, comment, or concern, please go to the Q&A window located in toolbar. Type in your question or comment, and we will try to get to your question or comment as we can during the webinar. This is being recorded and will be published to our internet page, www.cpg.org, in the coming days. With that, I will turn it over to our CEO and President, Mary Kate.
1:09 Mary Kate Wold: Thank you, Jermaine, and welcome, everybody, especially this week as we head into the holidays. I know everybody is very busy, and we’re grateful for you taking this time out this afternoon to be with us. This is a webinar we’ve been doing for several years just to complement our annual report. And I think we actually started it during COVID, and just gave us another opportunity to connect. But we thought that it was useful to be able to go over some of the highlights of our annual report, talk about our numbers, the work behind the numbers, our investment portfolio, and then to answer questions that are on people’s mind. And I know from questions we’ve already received, healthcare is on the minds of a lot of you, and we’ll be answering some of those questions.
1:54 Mary Kate Wold: We’ll actually weave the answers to some of the questions we’ve received to date from you into some of our conversation, but then we’re also going to save some time to entertain questions towards the end of this conversation as well. So delighted to have you here. We’re looking forward to this conversation, and I’m going to turn it over to the Reverend Canon Arlette Benoit Joseph, who is our chief church relations officer. She’s going to be moderating the discussion today, and I would like to ask her actually to begin the conversation with prayer. Arlette.
2:31 Canon Benoit Joseph: Thank you, Mary Kate. Happy to do so. Let us pray. Almighty and ever-living God, from whom all wisdom and understanding flows, we give you thanks for the gift of this day, for the ministries entrusted to our care, and for the privilege of serving your church. Bless our time together. Grant us wisdom in our deliberations, humility in our listening, clarity in our speaking, and grace in our conversations. Guide us in the faithful stewardship of the resources entrusted to us. Keep us ever mindful of the people and ministries we serve, and grant us compassion, courage, and discernment in all that we do. All this we ask in the mighty name of Jesus our Christ. Amen.
3:30 Canon Benoit Joseph: All right. Welcome, everyone. As Mary Kate said, today is a conversation, and we want you to be a part of it. I now have the pleasure of introducing to you two of my beloved colleagues. You’ve first heard from Mary Kate, our CEO and President, who helps keep us focused on the big picture: where we are, where we’re going, and how we prepare for the church’s future. Frank Armstrong is our Chief Operating Officer. He helps us turn that vision into the products and programs and services that support the church every day. And Michael Hood, our Chief Investment Officer, he helps us ensure that the resources entrusted to our care are invested wisely, not just for today, but for generations to come. Their full bios are available on our website at cpg.org. So if you want to learn a little bit more about them, you can head there. Mary Kate, Frank, and Michael, it’s always great to be in conversation with you. With that, let’s jump right in. You guys ready? Let’s go.
CPG’s listening work
4:44 Canon Benoit Joseph: All right. Mary Kate, my first question is to you. The theme of our annual report was Many Voices, One Purpose. And over the last two years, I feel like we’ve been around the church and back again. CPG has engaged church leaders and key stakeholders in conversations and other listening efforts. It’s been a multi-year effort running through next year and designed to help us build a strategic vision-relevant point of view. Can you describe a bit what prompted this work and why this was the right time for CPG to undertake it?
5:26 Mary Kate Wold: Thanks, Arlette. Yes, this involves, as Arlette said, some very important work that we’ve undertaken, which is to develop what we call a vision-relevant, meaning relevant to CPG in our work, vision-relevant point of view on where the church is going, on external factors, factors in our industries, and all of that with a view to better informing the work that we do, how we do our work internally, and the products and services that we provide to our clients. And as you might imagine, as a pension fund and a provider of healthcare, we have a lot of data on our clients. And we have a very talented research team who are able to take that data and do some predictive modeling. We share some of that with the church and what we’re actually seeing through that data. And then we’re also, many of us, out around the church all the time, as I am, and hear a lot of anecdotes.
6:23 Mary Kate Wold: But we can’t do our planning solely on backward-looking data. And as you know, in the investment world, they say past results are not indicative of future performance. I think it is. So we can’t[?] say that all this backward-looking data we have is necessarily going to be instructive as to where the church is going to be, in our industry, and the needs of the people we serve in the future. And at the same time, notwithstanding the many conversations we have around the church, we also can’t rely on anecdotal evidence. So what we set out to do in beginning in 2025 (we, incidentally, we do a strategic plan based on three-year increments, so this is ’25, ’26, ’27 that we’re doing this work), we set out to have many, many, many conversations that would collectively have some statistical significance, which I’ve actually tested with our research team. And they said, yes, that’s absolutely possible. And we’re close to getting there at that time, at this time.
7:24 Mary Kate Wold: So what does that mean? We’ve been having conversations with bishops and priests and deacons and lay employees and volunteers, wardens and vestrymen. We’ve been talking to industry and academic leaders. We’ve been talking amongst ourselves: what are some orthodoxies that we hold close, and do we need to re-examine them? And we’ve talked to hundreds and hundreds of people at this point in time. And we also just recently, a couple of months ago in September, sent out a survey specially customized for bishops, for priests and deacons, and for lay employees. And many people have responded to those, and for that, we’re very grateful. But that’s going to tie together a lot of the conversations that we’ve had. So we’re in a validation stage based on the conversations we’ve had. We’re going to be focusing on that in 2027. And by the end of 2027, we will have crystallized a point of view and also identified some of the most pressing areas that we need to look at in terms of our future work.
8:30 Mary Kate Wold: And when I say a point of view, it’s very clear that that’s not going to be some beautifully wordsmith statement, because the church is too varied. So we will have themes, but we’re going to have a lot of outliers that have to be described, because we serve everybody, all clergy, all lay employees. And therefore we have to be able to make sure that what we’re doing is going to be responsive to the needs of everybody. So that’s a tall order, but it’s really, really exciting work. And there’s nothing I like more about my job than being out around the church and talking to and finding out about the people we’re serving. So it’s a perfect vehicle for that for me as well.
How the investments support the pension fund
9:13 Canon Benoit Joseph: Excellent. Thank you. Mary Kate, I’d like to switch to a part of our business that is extremely important, but often misunderstood. And I was hoping you could explain how CPG’s investment team and our investment strategy helps us remain a stable source of support for the church amid these challenging times.
9:38 Mary Kate Wold: Sure. Well, again, it just occurred to me as you were introducing Michael Hood and Frank Armstrong, we have really the person who makes all the money in Michael Hood and the person who spends it all on our clients in Frank Armstrong. So you’ll hear from both of them today. But, you know, broad view of the portfolio and how we think of investing, and then I know that Michael is going to be getting into some of the details with you. But one thing to know is that the assessments that we get from churches for clergy (talking about the clergy plan for the moment), for clergy, do not nearly cover the cost of the benefits that we pay out. So for instance, we get in something around $90 million a year in assessments; we pay out at least $500 million a year. So more than five times the assessments coming in. And what does that mean? Well, that means that we need a lot of money in the portfolio to be able to throw off the kind of returns that we need to fill that gap of at least $400 million every single year.
10:43 Mary Kate Wold: And we need enough of a cushion to make sure that we can actually see our way through tumultuous periods in the markets, like the financial crisis or COVID, or even worse, if you look back to the 1970s, when we had 10 years of malaise and high inflation and such, where the portfolio really suffered. But we’re dedicated to making sure that we’re going to be able to continue to uphold our promises and not have to go back and reduce benefits to our clergy. Michael and I were just over in the UK and visiting with the Church of England Pension Fund, and they were describing the fact that they’ve just climbed out of the hole of having to reduce pensions, even for people who are currently retired. And finally, after many years, I think about 15 years, they’re able to reinstate the level of pensions that they had once paid. We hope never, ever, ever to be in that position of having to disappoint our participants and, more than that, put them in financial straits. So we maintain a significant cushion to be able to see us through those difficult periods. I think Michael’s probably going to talk about how we figure out how much that cushion should be to feel comfortable.
11:56 Mary Kate Wold: The other thing that I want to mention is that we have several pots of money that are very distinct. So the Clergy Pension Fund is one distinct pot of money that is devoted to paying retirement benefits to clergy. We also have a separate pot of money, legally separate, for the lay defined benefit plan, which is quite small and doesn’t nearly have the history of the clergy plan. We have the Medical Trust, which is also self-contained, and the revenues of Medical Trust are basically premiums that are paid by participants, but it doesn’t take money from the pension fund. And the same is true of our property and casualty companies. They’re basically, the income of those companies come from the premiums that are paid by participants. And each of these entities are managed financially and otherwise as standalone companies, and that legal distinction is very, very important for us to maintain.
13:02 Mary Kate Wold: I just want to say maybe a word, Arlette, about the lay DB plan. I know there’s a lot of disappointment oftentimes that we cannot pay a COLA in the lay DB plan the way that we’re able to, or have been able to, in the clergy plan, and that’s in part due to the fact that under General Convention’s mandate, the mandate was only for 9%, not the 18% for clergy. The plan is also much younger. It was started in the ’80s. So we haven’t had the time to really build up the nice amount of money that would enable us to pay COLAs. So we have to manage that very carefully. I think the 9% was actually calculated based on the amount that was just necessary to pay a retirement benefit without a COLA. So the bottom line there is maybe someday, if the portfolio does extremely, extremely well, but we’re sorry that we’re not in a position to do that now. But these have to be managed as very separate, legally separate pots of money.
Markets and risk
14:07 Canon Benoit Joseph: Thank you, Mary Kate. I think you teed things up well for Michael. I’d like to bring you into the conversation to discuss our investment work further. The markets hit all-time highs earlier this year, and most recently, we saw a significant decline. I’m wondering, Michael, if you can talk to us about how we position the portfolio for success, regardless of the market cycle.
14:34 Michael Hood: Certainly, Arlette. Thank you. Good to be with all of you today. Thanks for joining us. So, Arlette, we have to just start from the obvious premise that we are not prophets. We don’t know exactly what world we’re going to be living in over the next 10 years. And, you know, if we appropriate some language from Paul, as we look out over that time frame, we certainly see through a glass darkly. And so we need to build and maintain a portfolio that will do okay, regardless of the state of the world, what world we wind up living in. And the basic key to that is diversification. We diversify by investing in different asset classes, different geographies, different sectors of the economy, different investment managers. And so the portfolio is spread very, very widely.
15:26 Michael Hood: And we understand when we do that, that we’re giving something up basically in every single year, because we’re essentially ensuring that we’re not 100% invested in whatever the best performing asset is of the moment. But the more important thing from our perspective is that we are also guaranteeing that we’re not 100% invested in whatever the worst performing asset is of the moment. And in fact, we have some things in the portfolio that we know going in, most years aren’t going to do a lot for us, but will be a big help under certain circumstances. And we need to hold them now because we don’t know when those circumstances will strike. As you say, it’s conceivable that we’re going through a turn in the market cycle at the moment. But we’re not trying to call those short-term movements. We’re not really engaging in short-term speculation. What we do and what our investment managers do is focused on long-term value creation. We really want to put the power of compounding to work for us.
16:31 Michael Hood: As Mary Kate said, the key to the current position of the clergy plan is that it’s been in business since 1917. And it’s been managed by my predecessors prudently through that whole period. And so it’s built up the assets steadily. Compounding is magic, but that magic is most effective when you avoid large losses. And diversification is crucial to that.
16:58 Canon Benoit Joseph: Thank you, Michael. I have another one for you before I jump to some questions from our participants. You used the word diversification, and that’s certainly key, but preparing for the unknown is also important. We sit on the same floor, Michael, so I know that you spend a lot of time on stochastic asset liability modeling. That’s a mouthful of a statement. Also, liquidity stress testing for defined benefit plans. I’m wondering if you can break that down a little bit so we understand what this actually means and why we do it?
17:35 Michael Hood: Yes. These exercises are really just all about making sure that, as Mary Kate said, we can keep our promises come what may. So stochastic forecasting is really an exercise that recognizes that the central forecasts that we make about the portfolio are just the middle of a range of possible outcomes. And we go through an exercise of simulating those outcomes in a probabilistic manner to see what effect they have on our confidence that the pension plans will remain fully funded over the long run, meaning assets sufficient to meet the liabilities, even if, I shouldn’t say if, when we go through a significant downturn in financial markets.
18:25 Michael Hood: When we look at those probabilities, that gives us an indication of whether we’re comfortable with the expected returns and risks that we’ve got in the portfolio at the moment, or if we need to make some adjustments. And to Mary Kate’s earlier point, it also helps tell us whether we feel like we’re in position to give COLAs in each of the plans. So right now, that exercise suggests that, as Frank Armstrong likes to say, we’re in a yellow space, meaning we feel good about where we are. We’re confident that we can meet our obligations. Not so good that we can let our guard down or stop taking risk in the investment portfolio. We know we have to keep generating returns because we’ve got, we hope that we’re going to have liabilities for decades and centuries to come.
19:18 Michael Hood: We also spend, you mentioned the liquidity stress test. What that’s really about is we need to test our ability to raise cash out of the investment portfolio, because we need to do that each month in order to pay the benefits. As Mary Kate said, the pension assessments that we receive fall well short of covering the benefit payments that we make. And so each year we run an exercise, and we just finished it, we actually had the closing meeting about it this morning, where we assume a very negative market scenario that lasts for several years, and we walk through how we would raise cash sequentially over time to make it through that period and keep sending out the checks. And one thing that that does, in addition to reassuring us that we’ll be able to do it, is it actually gives us the plan, so that when we do get into that environment, that kind of environment, and I say again, when rather than if, we know what we’re going to do. And so that makes it less likely that we wind up making bad decisions under stress.
20:20 Michael Hood: So these exercises, sort of the tie between them is that each of them is about helping us ensure that we’re focusing on what we need to do to sustain the pensions over both the short term and the long run, and forces to keep thinking about what might go wrong and how we’ll handle those situations when they arise.
Participant questions: lay and clergy pensions
20:38 Canon Benoit Joseph: Excellent. Thank you, Michael. Frank, I have not forgotten about you, but I want to ask two questions before we move on, questions that have come in from our participants. So the first, well, I’ll ask two because these are related. (Reading participant questions:) “Is it possible to merge the clergy and lay buckets? What would it take to legally move toward merging, particularly as we see more lay people stepping into parish leadership roles?” And: “You keep mentioning that the clergy and lay benefit funds are legally separate. Could you please explain why they have to be separate?”
21:19 Michael Hood: Mary Kate, I think that’s one really for you.
21:21 Mary Kate Wold: Okay, well, I was once a lawyer. I’m not any longer, but I think I can answer these questions. First of all, one thing to note, incidentally, is that the vast majority of our active lay employees are not in a defined benefit plan. It’s the choice of either the diocese or the parish, but most are in defined contribution plans, which are very different animals. We have a fair number, I think probably under 3,000 people, totally in the lay defined benefit plan. So it’s a small percentage of the population, and most of those are all people who are already retired. These were created separately, excuse me, different legal entities created at different times, different funding structures, and different benefit structures. And if it were possible to merge them, I’m quite certain we couldn’t merge them with the result of giving higher benefits to the lay people coming into the plan at the expense of the clergy, if it were even possible. So it wouldn’t be a solution to giving disproportionate benefits to clergy whose assessments are significantly less than the, or to lay, whose assessments are disproportionately less than the clergy.
22:40 Mary Kate Wold: So these are highly regulated entities, and the regulators are very intent on protecting the participant, they’re very intent on protecting the participants in these plans. So there would be incredible hoops to jump through without the desired result ultimately of being able to disproportionately pay lay employees. So I don’t think that we could achieve the objective, even if, through kind of years of planning or regulatory hurdles, we could actually bring the two plans together. But again, I do want to remind people that most lay people, and this is a choice, parishes and dioceses have a choice of whether their lay employees will be in defined contribution plans, which are like 401(k), managed by Fidelity, or in defined benefit, and most of our lay employees are in defined contribution plans. Frank, would you like to add anything to that or clarify anything I said?
23:48 Frank Armstrong: I don’t think there’s much. We’ve studied this one. We’ve looked at it different ways. And as you started out, we’re regulated to not commingle those funds, because each one, each dollar was given to us for a specific reason. And we’re, you know, the regulators track that, make sure that it’s geared towards that. So, you know, we’ve studied to say, is there a loophole, a way around that? And I don’t think there is one, you know.
24:22 Michael Hood: One little comment I might make on this topic, Arlette, is that although the plans are legally separate, as Mary Kate and Frank said, for investment purposes, we do combine the assets and invest them side by side. And that’s a benefit to the lay plan, which is quite a bit smaller than the clergy plan. Because it’s able to ride along with the clergy plan from an investment perspective, it does have access to high-quality investments that would be difficult to get into for a plan of the size of the lay plan if it were a standalone. So it does at least have that benefit of being associated with the clergy plan in that sense.
25:03 Mary Kate Wold: Yeah, that’s a really important point, Michael. And it doesn’t undermine the legal separation of the two, but it does give the lay plan extra oomph, notwithstanding its much smaller size, and access. Excellent point.
Affordability, health care costs and GLP-1 coverage
25:20 Canon Benoit Joseph: All right. Thank you all. Frank, I promise that I will come back to you. So shifting gears slightly, we heard about our investment strategy and how it helps cover the gap between what we receive in assessments. Your teams are on the front lines of delivering the products, programs, and services our clients rely on. One of their concerns over the years has been around affordability, particularly around health care and insurance. I’m wondering if you can talk about what we’re doing to address those concerns. And I saved a lot of time for you. So tell us what you think.
26:03 Frank Armstrong: Thanks, Arlette. And before I get into that, I just feel like I have to clarify that, you know, Michael’s role is to make the money. My role is to spend it. But I have to ask our CFO, Ellen Taggart, permission first. So it just, you know, we have the checks and balances in place there. But seriously, yes, I mean, affordability is a consistent concern of our clients. We know that many clients are facing growing financial burdens. And so every, it’s basically factored into every decision we make. I can’t think of one where, you know, we focus on, well, why is the decision in front of us? What’s the value? But then we get to, well, what’s the intensity of effort and cost to deliver? And affordability always comes into that.
26:49 Frank Armstrong: So, you know, we know we operate businesses that are inherently volatile. So we’re constantly working that balance, you know, and doing it in a very purposeful way to make sure that we can meet the needs that, you know, the changing needs, but doing so in a way that is financially responsible. And for us, that financially responsible is twofold. Of course, we need to meet our financial commitments to our clients, both our short-term, medium, and long-term, as Michael and Mary Kate have talked about, but it’s also addressing the affordability piece. When we think about responsibility on our side, it’s twofold. And that really requires us to be very thoughtful in our decision-making and very often getting into these trade-off discussions. And health care is a clear example of that. You know, we’ve been successful over the last five years or so being able to hold premium increases to the mid-single digits. We’ve done that in a various number of ways. Every year we’re pulling whatever levers[?] we can. Overall, just focused on providing resources to improve the health outcomes.
27:59 Frank Armstrong: All that being said, affordability was even a concern during those years, and now that financial pressures are even getting more real, we’re faced with a healthcare industry that is accelerating in rising costs. So there’s not a conversation we have around healthcare that’s not striking that balance of how do we add value, how do we meet the needs, but do so in a financially responsible way. So, you know, that’s where we’re at right now. You know, we’ve seen, you know, we’ve been able to handle, you know, run our businesses. As Mary Kate said, the Medical Trust is its own legal entity. We run it purposely on razor-thin capital. Our capital is really there to have some money for unexpected claims and/or to help with volatility where we can, but we purposely don’t add anything on top of our annual premium increases each year to build up more capital, because we’re trying to do those razor-thin, in, you know, what do we need to pay out claims and have a little bit when things get rocky?
29:06 Frank Armstrong: Well, 2025 and ’26 were more than rocky. And we’re not unique in that. You know, we’re focused on, at the end of ’25, the second half, our claims came in 20% higher than we expected. And that continued to climb throughout 2026. You know, everything we see now, right now in the forecast, is continued double-digit increases in ’27. So that’s what we’re focused on now in terms of how do we continue to strike that balance. And without other revenue resources at this point, without making changes in 2027, we would have had to pass along over a 22% increase to our clients, and that just would not have been responsible. So it required us to take action. We had to make necessary changes to help stabilize things in ’27, because we expect ’27, ’28 and forward to continue to be volatile in the healthcare industry.
30:06 Frank Armstrong: You know, we made two significant changes. You know, one was raising deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums, basically across all of our plans, that did bring them more in line with industry benchmarks and other denominational peers, that our plans have always been purposely richer than others. But, you know, recent General Convention asked us to, you know, balance that better. We took steps, you know, this year to do that. And then the second piece was around GLP-1s. And, you know, we made the decision, the tough one, to stop covering them for the primary diagnosis of weight loss. So I want to spend some time unpacking that one a bit further.
30:45 Frank Armstrong: You know, first and foremost, it’s a very difficult decision. And it’s one we truly agonized over. Arlette, as you know, I’m personally still agonizing over it, when it’s a tough one, because we know that our clients, our members rely on these medications. And this decision was not based on ideological thought or any sort of value judgment. It really came down to economics and affordability. Our recent forecast, we’re seeing another spike right now of GLP-1 utilization in September, October, as some of the resources, some of these medications are now being available on pill-based[?]. So now our forecast, if we were to do nothing, would be over $10 million of additional costs that we would have to absorb by raising premiums at least 4% higher.
31:40 Frank Armstrong: And there’s also just strange, I’ll just call it strange economics that are happening with GLP-1s right now, that your manufacturers, the prices that they charge through health plans, through sort of group health plans, is more than twice the amount on average than consumers can get direct purchase price through the manufacturers. So there’s just this odd current economics around, you know, it’s not economically smart to buy these, you know, prescriptions through a health plan. So we’re just looking at something that right now these costs are rising in unsustainable levels. And this is even after we made adjustments in ’25 and ’26 to different body mass index levels and looking at other conditions, we just still see these costs increasing.
32:36 Frank Armstrong: So we did a bunch of research. We had a lot of discussions with our board, with Client Council[?], with other denominations, industry experts. We did look at short- and long-term financial impact. What are these costs now? Will there be savings down the road, and that sort of thing? But bottom line, the way this plan is structured, we would have to charge much more to be able to, if those savings do come in two, three years for now, and at a level that many of our employers just could not afford. And so we made that tough determination in mid-summer that, from everything we looked at, the most cost-effective way or approach that the church, under these current economic conditions, is to support access of these GLP-1s through direct consumer purchasing channels and not continue to do them through the health plan.
33:27 Frank Armstrong: So I just wanted to share, that’s sort of what we were faced with and how we were kind of wrestling that decision. And we know it’s a tough one. And we know that it’s sort of a shifting, somewhat, of financial burdens. We recognize that. And we just felt it was the prudent and responsible decision to make, to continue to be able to keep us a sustainable financial plan for the Medical Trust. So we began our communication campaign in August. And we had multiple ways, letters, emails, webinars with admins, with members of the Medical Trust, trying to get the message out. We contracted with Digbi Health. So this is a new resource that we were[?] making available in January of 2027. And long and short, it’s a virtual care platform. And it’s really geared at two things: providing personalized support for our members to, you know, for weight management, digestive health, diabetes, and other conditions, really earmarked at their specific, you know, each one of our own metabolisms and that sort of thing. But also, it’s a resource to help navigate purchasing of those GLP-1s at direct consumer pricing, which is considerably lower than what we can buy them through the health plan.
34:50 Frank Armstrong: Now, we know, and we’re hearing and we’re listening to our clients about, even though we’ve done a robust communication campaign with all the best efforts, some people were first finding out about this when they were making annual enrollment decisions and those sorts of things. So we’re listening to that. And what I will say right now is that we’re exploring, seeing if there’s additional transition support we can make without putting undue financial risk on the plan and on the employer. So we have that in front of us. We need to spend some time to figure out, is there some way, out-of-the-box way, that we can help, further help with this transition.
35:28 Frank Armstrong: I do want to shift gears a little bit, being, you know, wary of time here. Property casualty: also, affordability goes into all of our decision-making. We’re at similar cost concerns, but a different cycle, a different underwriting cycle, where, you know, five or so years, we’ve had straight, just significant losses of multiple catastrophic storms, different, you know, freeze events and all these sorts of things, which are really, um, hammering into our capital position. We’ve been blessed for the last two years that we’ve had some unexpected relief, so we’re able to build back some of that capital even more quickly than we had planned. So a different financial sort of position, you know, for the property casualty.
36:16 Frank Armstrong: But the same, we run the business the same way, razor-thin margins. It has to be self-sustainable. But our focus right now is on risk mitigation, help educate our clients to minimize losses when things do happen. We’re also able to be much more flexible in the products and policies that we’re able to make available as we go into 2027, to meet different needs, so that we can provide some premium relief as we go into 2027. So you’ll see some of that as we kind of move into the renewal year. So overall, it’s really focused on the same thing: controlling short-term costs, that affordability angle, maintaining long-term sustainability, and just that constant vigilance of balancing these trade-offs.
Quantum Health
37:06 Canon Benoit Joseph: All right. Thank you for that, Frank. I want to stick with you for a few more moments. There also continues to be talk about the Medical Trust members around Quantum Health and our decision to use them as a health care navigator. Can you give us an update on their work and future relationship?
37:29 Frank Armstrong: Yeah, certainly, Arlette. So first, at a very high level, description of a healthcare navigator, what our clients should expect and what we’re paying Quantum to do is, as the name suggests, to really help our members navigate the complexities of the healthcare system. So that’s help understand provider networks, referral requirements, identify appropriate sites of care. What are the other available resources? When should I think about telehealth? When should I think about urgent care, specialist care? You know, it’s that sort of navigation. But there’s also a clinical advocacy and education component of this, where, you know, we want Quantum to be helping our members understand diagnosis, you know, treatment options, help prepare questions for doctor visits, helping transitions of care from, you know, one facility to the next, and those sorts of things.
38:25 Frank Armstrong: And then there’s a blocking and tackling, the benefits and insurance support. So, you know, how to handle prior authorizations, when claim issues arise, when appeals, you know, need to be made. Quantum should help in all those areas, in this sort of single point of contact, where anything comes to our members’ mind, they should go to Quantum, find the answer either on that source, find a resource, or call a care coordinator and help them out. So, you know, that’s what we expect. We expect this ease of administrating burden for our members.
39:03 Frank Armstrong: And there are some positives. We are seeing very high member engagement of our members with all the resources through Quantum. Quantum has been very good at early intervention, so getting in, understanding, helping our clients achieve better health outcomes. We are seeing leading indicators of metrics of lower unnecessary emergency room visits, improved medication adherence, and those sorts of things.
39:29 Frank Armstrong: However, Quantum is not yet at the consistent delivery of what I call the blocking and tackling of some of those things. You know, we just, we know that our members are experiencing some, you know, very, or having varied experiences, and that’s not good. So we are actively engaged with Quantum, we have been, but even more so now, to really pinpoint why these inconsistencies happening, and focusing on very specific things like handling of prior authorizations. We have to get that to just a better overall level, and other claims issues that pop up, and helping being proactive and reaching out to providers and not telling our members to sort of solve it themselves, sort of thing. So those things don’t happen all the time, but there’s a consistency, or an inconsistency, that we’re talking to Quantum leadership about.
40:25 Frank Armstrong: I will say that we are also leveraging our relationships with our peers, our peer denominations who also use Quantum and have used them longer than I have. We have many of them. They are experiencing some similar concerns, and we have direct access to Quantum CEO. Mary Kate and I and other denomination leadership are meeting with the CEO of Quantum at the annual Church Benefits Association meeting in early December. And we’re talking specifically about: these are the areas that we expect actions to be taken. So we’re continuing that, as we also, with all our vendors, just do our normal due diligence. We’re looking at the marketplace for other evolving solutions. Are there different ways to get more of the good that we’re seeing from the navigator experience, and how do we get to address the gaps of some of the blocking and tackling?
41:23 Frank Armstrong: So our clients should expect, this is a heavy focus for us in 2027, continuing to have Quantum address these levels of inconsistency while we explore other possible options. What is the best solution going forward for our clients? But bottom line, we still feel navigation is needed. Our clients, we need to have our clients have resources to bear, to help with this advocacy, to help with everything that I explained before.
41:55 Canon Benoit Joseph: Okay. Thank you, Frank.
General Convention and trustee elections
41:57 Mary Kate Wold: Say, Arlette, before we run out of time, I want to just turn the tables a bit on you. And I want to make sure that we talk to our guests about our role at General Convention. In about six months or a little more, we’re going to be in Phoenix for General Convention. And if you could talk just a little bit, I want to make sure we squeeze this in, to talk about how we see our role at General Convention and what some of the conversations are that we’re having as we lead up to General Convention, if you don’t mind.
42:27 Canon Benoit Joseph: I don’t, what a plot twist! The moderator gets a question. Thank you for that question. Um, for CPG, it’s, General Convention is an important opportunity for us to strengthen relationships, engage in mutual education, and participate in the legislative process on matters that are relevant to our work. Our engagement is already underway. I know exactly how many days it is because we have a countdown. We’ve been attending provincial gatherings, meeting with bishops, deputies, other church leaders, hearing about the opportunities and challenges facing dioceses and congregations. These conversations help inform our work and how we prepare for the church’s future. I want to extend an invitation to anyone who might be considering submitting a resolution related to CPG’s work. We welcome the opportunity to be in conversation early in the process. Our hope is to be a helpful resource, providing information and context you need as you consider their resolutions and make decisions.
43:31 Canon Benoit Joseph: Another important aspect of General Convention for us is that General Convention would elect trustees for the Church Pension Fund Board. Four trustees are retiring, six incumbents are eligible for re-election, and two others who filled vacancies have terms ending. So this significant transition is important for us, and it just underscores the importance for continuity and fresh perspectives and strong governance. And finally, we look forward to seeing many of you in Phoenix. It’s 228 days away, to be exact, and we will be in 120-degree weather. You don’t want to be outside, so be sure to come see us at the exhibit hall booth. And we look forward to being there. We look forward to worshiping together, participating in conversations, and reconnecting in the hallways. It’s always a valuable time for us to listen and learn while we’re there. So thank you for that question, Mary Kate.
Participant questions: the transition, costs, Quantum and pensions
44:34 Canon Benoit Joseph: So, Frank, we have a few questions for you, and I want to try to get them in. You’ve mentioned some of it in what you’ve said, so I know that your answers can be brief. And then I have a final question for all of you to answer. So some of the questions involve GPL [sic], so I’m going to try to condense. We have a question about the transition period that you mentioned, Frank. So I don’t know if you want to give us a CliffsNotes version of that again, that we’ve seen the petition and we’re listening.
45:11 Frank Armstrong: Yeah, I just want to set our expectations, and that we’re, we don’t have, I don’t have an answer yet for that. Just that we’re listening, we hear it, um, and we are right now looking at, is there something that we can do leveraging, uh, you know, Digbi as a resource to try to help, uh, with additional, you know, some financial support, you know, in that sort of first quarter time. We just have to, we just have to try to figure that out, you know, and again, in a way that does not, um, you know, put the plan in financial risk. So we’re kind of pulling that apart now. And we’re trying to see if there’s, that’s what I’m talking about, that additional transitional support that we’re thinking about.
45:54 Canon Benoit Joseph: Thank you. Another one. (Reading a participant question:) “Healthcare costs in our diocese rose by 17% this year. This is unsustainable. But this problem doesn’t affect only us. It affects all religious organizations, all nonprofits, and all small businesses in the United States. How is CPG working with other similar groups to address this problem at the national level?”
46:18 Frank Armstrong: Yeah, there’s two ways. I guess, I guess I should say, you know, we’re in the same health plans as all of our members. So we’re dealing with the same, you know, pressures and, you know, trying to figure these things out. You know, we have, we work closely with the other large, especially large denominations in the Church Benefits Association to leverage purchasing coalitions when we can, to try to, uh, you know, press on, uh, you know, certain levels. We’re also, there’s a, there’s a separate, you know, arm of the, uh, church, uh, benefits alliance, it’s called. And that’s where the CEOs and other people, some legal folks of the largest denominations, spend time down at the Capitol Hill. We spend time saying, well, what are the issues in front of us? Where can we affect change?
47:17 Frank Armstrong: So we hit it sort of both levels: the macro level through, you know, through D.C. and those channels, and then the more micro level of what are the levers that we can pull, and is there scale that we can look at. We do sometimes think about, can we pool all of our risks together? But there’s just different polity and other things around the denominations that the actual benefits, you lose all the benefits of pooling that together when we can’t get alignment on that. Everybody’s aligned on how to cover X, Y, and Z certain type of things. So that is a challenge.
47:58 Canon Benoit Joseph: Frank, you again. (Reading a participant question:) “What should I do if Quantum is having trouble addressing my issues in a timely matter? Who at CPG can help with these issues?”
48:07 Frank Armstrong: Yeah, I always say, do, you reach out to our call center, you know, to our client service team, you know, because, you know, if you’re stuck and you just can’t get anywhere and you’re like, “I’m done,” you know, reach out to us. You know, they probably won’t, we probably won’t be able to answer that question immediately, but we can get the right people here to understand what’s going on and then find a way to get back to the member to say that. So that’s what I say. We don’t want anybody sort of suffering in silence. If there’s just, you know, you tried everything we put out there and it’s just not working, you know, reach out in that way. It’ll help us know also in terms of, you know, where we should continue to focus. Is that a one-off situation, or is there, you know, something bigger that we need to be looking at, paying attention to?
48:53 Canon Benoit Joseph: Okay. (Reading a participant question:) “Is there going to be a COLA for clergy pension next year?”
48:59 Mary Kate Wold: Well, the board has to, that’s a board decision that’s made in December. So, um, it’s a discretionary benefit, and that’s a board decision, September or December[?].
49:12 Canon Benoit Joseph: All right. I have one more. I think we have time for one more. It’s a bit long, so bear with me. (Reading a participant question:) “Please help us understand why the pension assessment charge to parishes on clergy compensation has been unchanged for many years at 18%, when the clergy pension plan is overfunded by nearly 300%, or $10 billion: $15.8 billion pension assessment [sic] versus $5.7 billion ABO. By comparison, J.P. Morgan, which has the most overfunded pension plan among the S&P 500, is overfunded by $8.9 billion, or only 160%. The average funding among the Milliman 100 is 104%. In the meantime, the financial health of individual parishes is under pressure due to double-digit increases in medical premiums and property insurance costs?”
50:16 Michael Hood: I can start on that one. Yeah. So I guess the first point to make is that the numbers you’re citing, it’s a great question, the numbers you’re citing would be the case if the plan were closed today, basically. But that’s not the case. The plan is open. And so really what that means is that we don’t know what the true values of the liabilities will be over time. They’ll rise with inflation, assuming the board continues to give COLAs. They change with the change in demographics of the church and so on. And this is a perpetual fund, we hope, and an ongoing fund.
50:57 Michael Hood: So the exercise that we were talking about earlier, the annual one that we run to simulate the various probabilities about what might happen to the investment assets and the liabilities and so on, suggests that, indeed, we’re pretty well funded, but it’s less than 1.5 times funded. So something in that range. And again, that’s a point in time. That can change. Financial markets drop suddenly, and then the funding status looks quite different. Or you get a big burst of inflation, funding status looks quite different. So, as said, we’re comfortable, but not on easy street by any means, and things can change. Mary Kate, I wonder if you want to talk about the point of view work and conversations with people in the church about the assessments, because I know this is certainly something that comes up.
51:56 Mary Kate Wold: The other thing I wanted to add to that, Michael, is when you look at a J.P. Morgan or another corporation, they have other corporate cash that they can put in if the plan runs into trouble. And if you’re a state pension plan, you have, you know, the opportunity to raise taxes and put in more money. We assume we can never go back to the church for more money. So we have to plan. And we don’t have the typical insurance that a corporate plan would have, the PBGC. So unlike almost any other pension plan out there, we have to go it on our own. And the assets we have in the pension plan are it. We have nothing to fall back on. So other plans can afford to have less of a surplus to be able to protect them against the downtime, because they have other access to other assets. We don’t have that. So that also enters into our deliberations when we think about the amount of assets that we have to be comfortable that we’re never going to be in the position that the Church of England was in during the financial crisis.
52:59 Frank Armstrong: Yeah, I was just going to add that, you know, this is one of our orthodoxies, as you mentioned on the point of view work, that, you know, we’re here for long haul. You know, we need to be here for, you know, the retirees today that have commenced the benefit, the active clergy, and then the next, you know, ordained cleric[?]. So we, when we look at, as Michael was talking about, you know, what we project out, that’s a liability that we’re looking at. And for us to make a commitment that, you know, this is sort of guaranteed, you know, as guaranteed as we can be, around being able to pay these benefits, that does cost quite a premium. You know, that’s the one and a half sort of, you know, level on that basis, that it costs seven billion or so to be able to say we can ride out, you know, those treacherous cycles, you know, in the economic cycle, so that we don’t turn, you know, unrealized losses into realized losses and then find ourselves trying to climb out of a hole.
54:01 Frank Armstrong: So it’s challenging. And that’s why we say, I do like to say, Michael, we’re in that yellow spot, is our sweet spot, you know, where we’re confident, but we’re cautious because of all these things that can happen. And that 8%[?], although it’s, 18% is not low, the actual benefits cost upwards of 30%. So, you know, we have to cover that gap as well.
54:29 Mary Kate Wold: So that was an excellent question, actually, and one that we get often, which is why I think it was worthwhile hearing from all of us and taking a little bit of time to explain our position on that. So thank you for the question.
Closing
54:42 Canon Benoit Joseph: Excellent. I have one final question for you. We have some other questions, but we have some elves working on responding to those privately and providing some information, because we are almost at time. And I really want to get this question in, because this question is for everyone, and you guys get to decide who goes first. And it’s: what’s one thing you want our listeners today to walk away from today’s conversation? I’d like for all of you to take a stab at that question before we log off. What is one thing that you want folks to take away from today’s conversation?
55:21 Mary Kate Wold: Well, I’ll jump in. What I want people to walk away from this conversation knowing is how deeply and passionately we at every level of the organization care about serving our clients well. And we might make decisions that are unpopular, GLP-1s, or how much money is in the plan to provide sufficient assurance for pensions, or no lay COLAs, but it’s done with deep and passionate care for all the people we serve, and the best information that we can assemble to make responsible decisions. And honestly, if someone in this organization doesn’t deeply and passionately care about the work we do and doing the right thing for our clients, they fairly quickly select out of the organization. So they’re a dedicated group of people here who really, really care.
56:15 Canon Benoit Joseph: Thank you, Mary Kate.
56:16 Michael Hood: Yeah, I’ll just add that on the investment side, we come at it from a point of view of stewardship. We’re managing the assets that back the benefits with a focus on the long term, carefully managing risk. And so our aim, which we’re confident we’ll be able to fulfill, is that the pensions will be well supported for many years to come.
56:41 Frank Armstrong: I just want everyone to know that I can’t spend money without asking Ellen. No, um, I would just go back to, it’s important for everybody to understand how we make decisions, and that we really do start with the value. We would say we make decisions of a value-cost lens, where we really spend the time being out with our clients to understand the needs, so that we can do what we can. We’re always looking at optimizing value. I like to say there’s nothing we intentionally do to our clients. We’re doing things for our clients. And we try to be very clear about setting expectations, transparent about our decisions. And so we do that.
57:29 Frank Armstrong: So if it’s not playing out the way that you’re hearing us, reach out to us and just say, “I heard this. I’m experiencing this. Help me,” you know, sort of thing. You know, whether it’s, you know, a Quantum experience, or just, you know, “I heard you talk about the decision-making around whatever. You know, did you contemplate something else?” So we want to hear from our clients. We actually do listen. We listen a lot. It’s part of our discernment and our thoughtful decision-making. And we try to be extremely transparent with our decisions, as Mary Kate said, even when, I mean, especially when, we know they’re not the most popular ones.
58:08 Canon Benoit Joseph: Excellent. Thank you. Thank you all. Thank you for sharing your insights and perspectives. Before I turn things back over to Mary Kate to wrap up, I want to acknowledge that we received a question about mental health support. So this is me getting on my soapbox about EAP, and visiting cpg.org/EAP to learn more. You can also call Quantum as well, and that number is available on our website. You are not alone. Today’s conversation really speaks to the theme of our annual report, Many Voices, One Purpose: listening, learning, and engaging with one another. If you have not yet taken a read of it, it is well done. Our team did a great job. That, too, is on our website. So please, please take a read of that. And speaking of many voices, we want to hear from you, so please continue to reach out to us. And with that, Mary Kate, I turn things over to you.
59:08 Mary Kate Wold: Thank you, Arlette. You took the words out of my mouth. I just want to thank everybody for attending today. This webinar is being recorded, and you’ll be able to access it on our YouTube channel. So if you want to listen to all this again, or refer a friend, then look to our YouTube channel. And also just encourage you to follow us on social media. And if you’re not a client, you can subscribe to receive our communications at cpg.org/stayconnected. So again, thank you very much. I hope everybody has a safe and wonderful Thanksgiving coming up. And we’re very grateful for you being here. Have a good day.